via Archaeology with Flint Dibble, 21 February 2024: Archaeologist Flint Dibble holds an “open peer review” of the controversial Gunung Padang paper with Indonesian archaeologists Lufti Yondri and Harry Sofian (the former having actually excavated Gunung Padang) to give a breakdown of the many criticisms of the paper. The criticisms have been outlined several times before (see here, here and here) but it boils down to the conclusions in the paper not being supported by the evidence presented.
Comments 1