• via Da Nang Today, 20 Sep 2023: The Da Nang Museum of Cham Sculpture recently hosted an academic event showcasing Dong Duong Buddhist art as part of an educational series aimed at students studying history, culture, architecture, and tourism.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/21/students-explore-champa-buddhism-through-dong-duong-art/
  • via various news sources, 20 September 2023: Cambodia is celebrating the listing of Koh Ker Temple as a UNESCO World Heritage Site with nationwide events, including slideshows and drumbeats, aimed at fostering national pride and unity.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/20/cambodia-celebrates-koh-ker-temples-unesco-world-heritage-status/
  • via Khmer Times, 19 September 2023: Preah Vihear, once a flashpoint in Cambodian-Thai relations, now thrives as a UNESCO World Heritage site, attracting thousands of tourists.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/20/preah-vihear-from-conflict-zone-to-must-see-heritage-site/
  • via Khmer Times, 19 September 2023: A unique two-storey structure with overlapping platforms of different designs has been discovered at Bayon Temple during restoration work, offering new insights into ancient Khmer architectural practices.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/20/unique-two-storey-structure-found-at-bayon-temple/
  • via Khmer Times, 19 September 2023: Chinese and Cambodian experts met to discuss the conservation of Preah Vihear temple
  • via the Thaiger, 19 September 2023: Si Thep Historical Park in Thailand is attracting tourists with unique ice cream designs based on ancient patterns found at the site, available until September 24 during the Si Thep World Heritage Celebration.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/20/si-theps-ice-cream-draws-tourists-and-history-buffs/
  • via Vietnam Plus, 18 September 2023: The Ho Chi Minh City Museum of History has captivated audiences with an exhibition featuring over 170 artifacts from four Vietnamese dynasties, aiming to foster national pride and cultural preservation.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/20/ho-chi-minh-city-museum-unveils-vietnams-dynastic-treasures/
  • via Phnom Penh Post, 17 September 2023: The Tuol Sleng Genocide Museum in Phnom Penh serves as a focal point for remembering the Khmer Rouge era, complemented by 81 memorial stupas across Cambodia that preserve the remains and stories of the victims.

https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2023/09/20/tuol-sleng-and-beyond-cambodias-81-memorial-sites-unveil-a-haunting-past/
  • via CGTN, 19 September 2023: China has played a significant role in restoring Cambodia
  • via various news sources, 19 September 2023: The fire at the National Museum of Indonesia impacted 817 artifacts but spared Prince Diponegoro
Friday, September 22, 2023
SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology
  • ResourcesStart here
  • Countries
    • Southeast Asia
    • Mainland Southeast Asia
      • Cambodia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Island Southeast Asia
      • Brunei
      • Indonesia
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Timor Leste
    • Peripheral Southeast Asia
  • Topics
    • Artifact Type
      • Architecture
      • Bones and Burials
      • Ceramics
      • Intangible Cultural Heritage
      • Lithics
      • Megaliths
      • Rock Art
      • Sculpture
    • Field
      • Anthropology
      • Bioarchaeology
      • Epigraphy
      • General Archaeology
      • Metallurgy and Metalworking
      • Paleontology
      • Underwater Archaeology
      • Visual Art
      • Zooarchaeology
    • Other Themes
      • Animism
      • Buddhism
      • Christianity
      • Disaster Risk Management
      • Hinduism
      • Islam
      • Archaeological Tourism in Southeast Asia
  • Research
    • Online Lecture Library
    • Journals and Papers
    • Data Repositories and References
    • Archaeological Projects in Southeast Asia
    • Libraries
    • Books
    • Conferences
    • Laws and Legislation
    • Archaeology Education in Southeast Asia
    • Digital Tools and Software
  • Visit
    • Virtual Archaeology
    • Exhibitions
    • Museums
    • Unesco World Heritage
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • About
    • Supporters
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology
  • ResourcesStart here
  • Countries
    • Southeast Asia
    • Mainland Southeast Asia
      • Cambodia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Island Southeast Asia
      • Brunei
      • Indonesia
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Timor Leste
    • Peripheral Southeast Asia
  • Topics
    • Artifact Type
      • Architecture
      • Bones and Burials
      • Ceramics
      • Intangible Cultural Heritage
      • Lithics
      • Megaliths
      • Rock Art
      • Sculpture
    • Field
      • Anthropology
      • Bioarchaeology
      • Epigraphy
      • General Archaeology
      • Metallurgy and Metalworking
      • Paleontology
      • Underwater Archaeology
      • Visual Art
      • Zooarchaeology
    • Other Themes
      • Animism
      • Buddhism
      • Christianity
      • Disaster Risk Management
      • Hinduism
      • Islam
      • Archaeological Tourism in Southeast Asia
  • Research
    • Online Lecture Library
    • Journals and Papers
    • Data Repositories and References
    • Archaeological Projects in Southeast Asia
    • Libraries
    • Books
    • Conferences
    • Laws and Legislation
    • Archaeology Education in Southeast Asia
    • Digital Tools and Software
  • Visit
    • Virtual Archaeology
    • Exhibitions
    • Museums
    • Unesco World Heritage
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • About
    • Supporters
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

Source: Woravatin et al. 2023

[Paper] Unlocking Secrets of Southern Thai Genetics: Surprising South Asian Linkages

18 September 2023
0
14

...

Source: Cosmos 20230915

Pang Pang Excavation Unlocks Mysteries of the First Pacific Settlers

18 September 2023
0
7

...

Source: Archaeology Review 20230828

Unlocking the Real Mysteries of Gunung Padang: Separating Fact from Fiction

29 August 2023
0
105

...

[Talk] Visible and invisible culture of the Punan Bah – a fifty-year journey of documentation

[Talk] Visible and invisible culture of the Punan Bah – a fifty-year journey of documentation

28 August 2023
0
24

...

Popular This Week

  • Archaeologist Damian Evans at Beng Melea. Source: Phnom Penh Post 20150428

    [Obituary] Damian Evans

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Negritos or Malays: Who are the original inhabitants of the Philippines?

    2 shares
    Share 2 Tweet 0
  • Si Thep Historical Park on the Cusp of UNESCO World Heritage Status

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Yogyakarta’s Cosmological Axis: A New UNESCO World Heritage Site

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Discover Ancient Kedah: Bridging Histories Between Thailand and Malaysia

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
Buy me a coffeeBuy me a coffee

If you found this site useful, you can help support it by buying me a coffee!

Home » Malaysia » Rebutting the myth that Malays have the second oldest genes in the world

Rebutting the myth that Malays have the second oldest genes in the world

6 August 2018
in Malaysia
Tags: "Out of Sundaland" modelAustronesian (peoples)DNAgeneticsHomo sapienshuman evolutionHuman Genome Organisation (HUGO)Human Genome ProjectIban (people)indigenous peoplesMaude E Phipps (person)migrationNationalismOrang Asli (people)pseudoarchaeologyrace and ethnicityStephen Oppenheimer (person)Zaharah Sulaiman (person)
25
SHARES
12.6k
VIEWS
Rebutting the myth that Malays have the second oldest genes in the world

Malaysia has a complex history of ethnonationalism, in which people who are identified as Malay (but more accurately native Malaysians) are given special privileges over other ethnic groups in the country. This has led to a number of social, economic and political problems but the one that I want to highlight here is the misuse of science and archaeological research to advance this agenda. Last week, a historian speaking at the ominously named “The Origins of the Malay” forum “quoted” the work of the Human Genome Organisation and said that after the Africans, the Malays have the second oldest genetic lineages in the world, even going so far as to imply that the Malays were ultimately responsible for establishing the Chinese and Greek civilizations.

This is some next-level ridiculousness but the misuse of archaeology for the promotion of ethnonationalism is not new in Malaysia, particularly when it comes to genetics, and we have seen examples before here and here. I’m glad that the authors from the Human Genome Organization whose research were misquoted and misused issued a rebuttal, but I also wish that the journalist and editors from the Malay Mail had done some basic fact-checking as well. I reproduce the main rebuttals here:

As academicians who have been funded largely through grants from the Ministry of Science, Technology and Innovation, Ministry of Higher Education of Malaysia, the UK government and our respective institutions, we are duty bound to address the dubious statements that do not stand to factual or scientific scrutiny, and only serve to misinform and confuse the public.

1. We must unequivocally state that there are no such things as Malay genes, Chinese genes, Indian genes, etc. All of humanity are Homo sapiens with Homo sapiens genes.

2.  Zaharah is reported to have said that “roughly 60,000 to 75,000 years ago, there was a migration by some of the shortest people from humanity’s cradle in Africa to Sundaland, which is now known as Southeast Asia”.

This seems inconceivable and illogical. How could these “first migrants” have been the “shortest people” and how could they have skipped the landmasses between Africa and Southeast Asia such as the Arabian Peninsula, Middle East, Levant and Indian subcontinent to get to Southeast Asia? There are clear archaeological evidences of the existence of Anatomically Modern Humans (AMH) from the following sites that have been carbon dated. For example, Jebel Qattar (75 thousand years ago (kya), Mundafan (100-80 kya), Aybut Al Awual (105 kya) and Jebel Faya C (125 kya); in Levant Qafzeh (120-90 kya); and 16R Dune (96-80 kya), Jwalapuram (85-75 kya).

3. She is reported to have said that “The study conducted by the Human Genome Organisation (Hugo) that was published in 2013 showed that the ancestors of the Malay people, the Semang and Senoi, migrated to the ancient kingdom of Champa that is now located in parts of Vietnam and Cambodia.”

We are members of the Human Genome Organization and can verify that there was no such publication in 2013.  What we did publish were papers in 2011 and 2014 that elucidated genetic variants among various Malay sub-populations. We found no evidence whatsoever that Senoi and Semang were directly related to Malays. The Champa were never mentioned. The Malaysian Negrito (also known as Semang) and Senoi groups are Austro-Asiatic speakers, while Malays are Austronesian speakers. Both groups are genetically distinct from each other.

4. She has been reported to have claimed “From Semang and Senoi came the rest of the ethnic tribes including the indigenous peoples such as the orang Asli, Iban, Dayaks and so on. In fact, the Malays’ closest ancestor is the Jakun tribe”.

This statement is fundamentally flawed and misleading. There are 3 main groups of Orang Asli in peninsular Malaysia ― Negrito, Senoi and Proto-Malay (of which Jakun is a sub group). Jakun and Malays are genetically related. However, there is no strong evidence to prove that Jakun are ancestral to Malays. Neither is there any evidence to prove that Semang (Negrito) and Senoi are the ancestors of the Iban or Dayak in Borneo.

5. She was also reported to have said that “based on scientific evidence, the Malay set of mtDNA is 63,000 years old when compared to the Chinese mtDNA that is 43,000 years old. The youngest set of mtDNA in the world belongs to the South American civilisation at 10,000 years old.”

The mtDNA is inherited from mothers and is used to roughly estimate departure from our female ancestors. It contributes only 0.00005% of total human DNA/genes and is less stable than nuclear DNA (99.99995 per cent) in cells. Population genetics does not rely solely on mtDNA to draw conclusions about human ancestry, evolution or migration. To do so now would be inaccurate and unreliable. We always consider maternal, paternal genetics and the bigger picture.

The rebuttals were issued by Prof Dr Maude E Phipps (Monash University Malaysia), Prof Dr Hoh Boon Peng (UCSI University Malaysia, Prof Dr Stephen Oppenheimer (Oxford University), Prof Dato’ Dr Mahani Mansor-Clyde (formerly at Universiti Kebagsaan Malaysia) and Dr Farhang Aghakhanian (Monash University Malaysia).

See also:

  • Historian: Malay genes second oldest in the world | Malay Mail, 02 August 2018
  • Rebutting Zaharah Sulaiman on Malay genes second oldest in the world ― Maude E Phipps | Malay Mail, 04 August 2018

Subscribe to the weekly Southeast Asian Archaeology news digest

Latest Books

The following are affiliate links for which I may earn a commission if you click and make a purchase. Click here for more books about Malaysian archaeology.
Sale Selected Topics on Archaeology, History and Culture in the Malay World
Selected Topics on Archaeology, History and...
Amazon Prime
$125.96
Buy on Amazon
Sale Rainforest Foraging and Farming in Island Southeast Asia: the Archaeology of the Niah Caves, Sarawak (McDonald Institute Monographs)
Rainforest Foraging and Farming in Island...
$92.45
Buy on Amazon
Malay Seals from the Islamic World of Southeast Asia
Malay Seals from the Islamic World of Southeast...
Amazon Prime
$150.00
Buy on Amazon
Traces of the Ramayana and Mahabharata in Javanese and Malay Literature
Traces of the Ramayana and Mahabharata in Javanese...
Amazon Prime
$30.00
Buy on Amazon
The archaeology of the Niah Caves, Sarawak: Volume II
The archaeology of the Niah Caves, Sarawak: Volume...
$99.98
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2023-09-21 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API


Comments 16

  1. Liz says:
    5 years ago

    Oòoooh. More wild claims of Malay “supremacy “.

  2. Khairul says:
    5 years ago

    The indian, chinese, slav, saxon, aryan, levant and others races were originated from malay anscestor

  3. Noel Tan says:
    5 years ago

    Your statement is objectively wrong and you obviously haven’t read the article either.

  4. knowUrMalay says:
    5 years ago

    Negritos could be as old as Africans & older than other races but Malays 2nd oldest race? Not even close.

  5. BK says:
    5 years ago

    Khairul, dont take this 60k years dark secret when u travelling outside Malaysia, the whole world will laugh at your ignorance at best… Lol

  6. William Khoo says:
    4 years ago

    If you think that you are right mr.author a chinese as i am,go and face her.challenge her by academic proof.she did mtdna research what have tou got?

  7. Cloud Chaser says:
    4 years ago

    William Khoo…I agree with u..she did the research n the writer just create some denial fact… ignorance will always want to win although he knows the actual fact

  8. Shani says:
    4 years ago

    Rebuttal is useless without mtDNS proof.. talk is cheap lets see the evidence

  9. Bukan Bapak Kau says:
    4 years ago

    “Jakun and Malays are genetically related. However, there is no strong evidence to prove that Jakun are ancestral to Malays”

    These statements are contradicting by itself. Try to make sense out of it.

    I don’t care about the relation between Malays and Senoi/Semang, genetically we are different, also by language. That I could agree. However Malays are related to Proto-Malays, this has been researched by academicians in the past multiple times, and its observable not just by genetics, but also culturally and linguistically. They represent the Malay people before intermarriage and contact with other cultures. After all, they (Jakun, Temuan, and others) were grouped as “Proto-Malays” by anthropologies for obvious reason.

    Seems like these UCSI and Monash profs were also trying to assert their twisted views on others. No difference.

  10. Noel Tan says:
    4 years ago

    On the contrary, the statements make sense – the Jakun and Malays are ‘cousins’ (so the speak): they are genetically related, but one is not ancestral to the other. Groupings were established based on the available evidence, groupings should change as new evidence presents itself.

  11. Dunter says:
    4 years ago

    This finding will make other people think the Malays are just boasting themselves. But the truth is, all the puzzles that the ancient people left long time ago will be discovered soon. This might sounds ridiculous but as a human, put away all the negative thinking. Do the research. Connect and relate all the academics findings and research and at the end, we will find the answer. Believe me

  12. lima says:
    4 years ago

    the malays are mix of austronesian and austroasiatic.. their have complex gene so far in south east asia.. you should do more research and blaming the researcher.. their have facts and if you have facts, please talk to the researcher your arguments..

  13. Jack says:
    3 years ago

    So Malays are related to Proto-Malay, one of the earliest family. That’s all you need to know. Respect their rights.

  14. James Harvard says:
    3 years ago

    denial syndrome is typical for communist or racist mentality.. they are good in spinning around cause hatred stupidity

  15. I love Malaysia says:
    3 years ago

    “Meanwhile, the Proto-Malays who arrived later than Negritos in 2000 BC were seafaring people and settled mostly in the central and southern regions of Peninsular Malaysia [1], [11]. They are Austronesian speakers apart from one tribe, (the Semelai) who speak Aslian [9] and embrace people who are similar in appearance to the Malays but of diverse origins, some probably having entered the region by sea in recent centuries whilst others may have been living in the peninsula for thousands of years [9], [10]. In contrast, the present-day Malays of the Malay Peninsula are described as Deutero-Malays, the descendants of the Proto-Malays who had admixed with Siamese, Javanese, Sumatran, Indian, Thai, Arab and Chinese traders [12]. However, according to Fix [10], the original Deutero-Malays migrated from southern China (after the migration of the Proto-Malays) over 1500 years ago and their intermarriages with the Proto-Malays and traders of the ancient trade routes resulted in the diverse recent Deutero-Malay populations that became known currently as the Malays. Hence, Malay population structure analysis would not just provide the information on the genetic differentiation between the populations but would also provide insight into the relationship with the indigenous populations in Peninsular Malaysia.”

    https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3071720/

  16. Dinbatupahay says:
    3 years ago

    By Sailing. Melayar_melayuik.

Leave a ReplyCancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology

© 2019

Navigate Site

  • Resources
  • Countries
  • Topics
  • Research
  • Visit
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About

Follow

No Result
View All Result
  • Resources
  • Countries
    • Southeast Asia
    • Mainland Southeast Asia
      • Cambodia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Island Southeast Asia
      • Brunei
      • Indonesia
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Timor Leste
    • Peripheral Southeast Asia
  • Topics
    • Artifact Type
      • Architecture
      • Bones and Burials
      • Ceramics
      • Intangible Cultural Heritage
      • Lithics
      • Megaliths
      • Rock Art
      • Sculpture
    • Field
      • Anthropology
      • Bioarchaeology
      • Epigraphy
      • General Archaeology
      • Metallurgy and Metalworking
      • Paleontology
      • Underwater Archaeology
      • Visual Art
      • Zooarchaeology
    • Other Themes
      • Animism
      • Buddhism
      • Christianity
      • Disaster Risk Management
      • Hinduism
      • Islam
      • Archaeological Tourism in Southeast Asia
  • Research
    • Online Lecture Library
    • Journals and Papers
    • Data Repositories and References
    • Archaeological Projects in Southeast Asia
    • Libraries
    • Books
    • Conferences
    • Laws and Legislation
    • Archaeology Education in Southeast Asia
    • Digital Tools and Software
  • Visit
    • Virtual Archaeology
    • Exhibitions
    • Museums
    • Unesco World Heritage
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • About
    • Supporters
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

© 2019

All the news in one weekly email

×
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.