• Terracotta elephant statue from the pre-Thang Long period, approximately 8-10th century. On display at the museum under the National Assembly Building in Hanoi. #vietnamarchaeology #southeastasianarchaeology #vietnam #hanoi #thanglong #terracotta #elephant #ceramics #ancientart
  • Earlier this week there was a news article about a Thai archaeologist’s attempt to repatriate a statue that was reportedly looted from Buriram province and now on display at the Metropolitan Museum of Art.
https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2022/07/08/thai-archaeologist-on-mission-to-reclaim-ancient-khmer-sculpture-from-us/

This is the so-called Golden Boy, taken at the Met last December. The label calls it a Standing Shiva(?) and attributes it to the Cambodia, Siem Reap origin but it may be in fact a representation of Jayavarman Vi. You can see the museum info here: https://www.metmuseum.org/art/collection/search/39097?ft=khmer&offset=0&rpp=40&pos=3

#khmer #sculpture #looting #antiquitiestrade #themet #metropolitanmuseumofart #khmerarchaeology #thaiarchaeology #southeastasianarchaeology #southeastasia #museums #repatriation #angkor #cambodia #thailand #buriram
  • What’s in your field kit? Here’s what’s in mine: https://www.southeastasianarchaeology.com/2022/07/04/whats-in-my-archaeology-field-kit-june-2022/ #fieldwork #fieldgear #camera #drone #archaeology #photography #videography
  • Last month I received the latest publication from the Getty Conservation Institute entitled Networking for Rock Art, focusing on public engagement. I have a small contribution very aptly named “Leave a Like and Subscribe” 😅 You can download a copy here: https://www.getty.edu/conservation/publications_resources/pdf_publications/networking_for_rock_art.html#:~:text=Networking%20for%20Rock%20Art&text=This%20volume%20by%20the%20Rock,are%20addressed%20through%20local%20action. #rockart #publicarchaeology #communityarchaeology #southeastasianarchaeology #freebook #book #gettyconservationinstitute
  • A cocktail is an unlikely candidate for an archaeology-based feed, but it turns out that the iconic Singapore Sling of the Long Bar at @raffleshotelsingapore  was a favourite of Dutch prehistorian van Stein Callenfels. No doubt, lithics work makes one thirsty. #singaporesling #rafffleshotel #longbar #indonesianarchaeology #malaysianarchaeology #singaporearchaeology #pietervansteincallenfels #southeastasianarchaeology #travelsingapore #visitsingapore #singaporetourism #singapore #cocktails
.
.
For those who haven’t tried it, the Singapore Sling is essentially a boozy fruit punch. It was also designed for the ladies but I guess that didn’t stop Ivan the Terrible!
  • After several false starts due to the year-end supply chain disruptions I finally got my hands on my colouring book! Link in Bio. Some of my earlier drawings are cruder than the later ones but overall happy with the final product. Thanks everyone who supported this book! If you bought a copy, it would help greatly if you left a review on Amazon. Some of my Buy Me a Coffee members will be getting a copy soon :) #southeastasianarchaeology #coloringbook #weekendproject #patronreward
  • Short @seameospafa work trip to visit the Ban Kao National Museum in Kanchanaburi province. The archaeological investigations in Ban Kao marked the beginning of archaeology with collaborations between Thai and International teams. More in my IG Story, ‘Ban Kao Muséum’ #bankao #bankaonationalmuseum #kanchanaburi #thailand #thaiarchaeology #southeastasianarchaeology #museum #drone #บ้านเก่า #prehistoric #travelthailand #visitthailand #thaitourism
  • Happy New Year of Tiger! In Vietnam, the Lunar New Year is called Tết Nguyên Đán. This tiger is fom the Ngoc Son temple in Hanoi. #hanoi #ngocson #hoankiem #tiger #lunarnewyear #tet #chinesenewyear #yearofthetiger #yearofthetiger2022 #southeastasia #southeastasiaculture #ngocsontemple #southeastasianarchaeology
  • Last post for the year! In between SPAFACON going on this week and being on vacation for the rest of the year, I am all tapped out for IG posts for now. I will return again next year, with more sites and artifacts from Southeast Asia! This is Wat Phrathat Chedi Luang in the ancient city of Chiang Saen in northern Thailand
  • Last post for the year! In between SPAFACON going on this week and being on vacation for the rest of the year, I am all tapped out for IG posts for now. I will return again next year, with more sites and artifacts from Southeast Asia! This is Wat Phrathat Chedi Luang in the ancient city of Chiang Saen in northern Thailand
Tuesday, August 9, 2022
SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology
  • ResourcesStart here
  • Countries
    • Southeast Asia
    • Mainland Southeast Asia
      • Cambodia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Island Southeast Asia
      • Brunei
      • Indonesia
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Timor Leste
    • Peripheral Southeast Asia
  • Topics
    • Artifact Type
      • Architecture
      • Bones and Burials
      • Ceramics
      • Intangible Cultural Heritage
      • Lithics
      • Megaliths
      • Rock Art
      • Sculpture
    • Field
      • Anthropology
      • Bioarchaeology
      • Epigraphy
      • General Archaeology
      • Metallurgy and Metalworking
      • Paleontology
      • Underwater Archaeology
      • Visual Art
      • Zooarchaeology
    • Other Themes
      • Animism
      • Buddhism
      • Christianity
      • Disaster Risk Management
      • Hinduism
      • Islam
      • Tourism
  • Research
    • Online Lecture Library
    • Journals and Papers
    • Data Repositories and References
    • Archaeological Projects in Southeast Asia
    • Libraries
    • Books
    • Conferences
    • Laws and Legislation
    • Education
    • Digital Tools and Software
  • Visit
    • Virtual Archaeology
    • Exhibitions
    • Museums
    • Unesco World Heritage
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • About
    • Supporters
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology
  • ResourcesStart here
  • Countries
    • Southeast Asia
    • Mainland Southeast Asia
      • Cambodia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Island Southeast Asia
      • Brunei
      • Indonesia
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Timor Leste
    • Peripheral Southeast Asia
  • Topics
    • Artifact Type
      • Architecture
      • Bones and Burials
      • Ceramics
      • Intangible Cultural Heritage
      • Lithics
      • Megaliths
      • Rock Art
      • Sculpture
    • Field
      • Anthropology
      • Bioarchaeology
      • Epigraphy
      • General Archaeology
      • Metallurgy and Metalworking
      • Paleontology
      • Underwater Archaeology
      • Visual Art
      • Zooarchaeology
    • Other Themes
      • Animism
      • Buddhism
      • Christianity
      • Disaster Risk Management
      • Hinduism
      • Islam
      • Tourism
  • Research
    • Online Lecture Library
    • Journals and Papers
    • Data Repositories and References
    • Archaeological Projects in Southeast Asia
    • Libraries
    • Books
    • Conferences
    • Laws and Legislation
    • Education
    • Digital Tools and Software
  • Visit
    • Virtual Archaeology
    • Exhibitions
    • Museums
    • Unesco World Heritage
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • About
    • Supporters
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact
No Result
View All Result
SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology
No Result
View All Result
ADVERTISEMENT

Related Posts

St Paul's Hill. Source: The Star 20220730

Group to gather records on Melaka history to preserve heritage

August 5, 2022
0
21

...

St Paul's Hill. Source: The Star 20220730

Renaming of St Paul Hill to Bukit Melaka must be based on actual state history, says activist

August 2, 2022
0
11

...

Source: The Star, 20220707

A living legacy

July 11, 2022
0
23

...

Source: The Malaysian Insight 20211118

Gerakan promises to nominate Baba Nyonya, Kristang heritage for Unesco list

November 22, 2021
0
18

...

Popular This Week

  • Source: Scroll.in 20220803

    Why did Sumatran kings once build a Buddhist monastery in Tamil Nadu?

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • [Book] Asia-Pacific heritage conservation benefits from ‘cultural landscape’ approach

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • [Paper] Early Austronesians Cultivated Rice and Millet Together: Tracing Taiwan’s First Neolithic Crops

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • National Museum seeks traditional Khmer household items for conservation, exhibition

    0 shares
    Share 0 Tweet 0
  • Rebutting the myth that Malays have the second oldest genes in the world

    25 shares
    Share 25 Tweet 0
Buy me a coffeeBuy me a coffee

If you found this site useful, you can help support it by buying me a coffee!

Home » Malaysia » Untangling myth and reality from Malaysia's history

Untangling myth and reality from Malaysia's history

January 24, 2012
in Malaysia
Tags: Bukit Cina (site)Hang Li Po (person)Hang Tuah (person)historiographyKhoo Kay Kim (person)Malacca (city)Malacca Sultanate (kingdom)Malay Annals / Sulalatus Salatin (literary work)NationalismPalembang (city)
0
SHARES
409
VIEWS

Besides the “startling” news about the origins of the human race, another stir over the history of Malaysia was raised last week when eminent Malaysian historian Professor Khoo Kay Khim declared that some of the characters and stories in Malaysia’s national historical narrative were probably mythical or did not actually exist. Among those figures was the warrior Hang Tuah and the Chinese princess Hang Li Po.

Sculpture of Hang Tuah at the Malaysian National History Museum, wikicommons image
Sculpture of Hang Tuah at the Malaysian National History Museum, wikicommons image


Malaysia’s history books are due for a revamp in 2014, and Professor Khoo sits on the review committee. Malaysia’s historical narrative tends to emphasise (even begin with) the role of the Malacca Sultanate, founded in the 15th century. The history of the Malacca Sultanate is based largely on the Malay Annals (Sejarah Melayu, but more formally the Silla-leteh-al-salatin or Sulalatu’l-Salatina – the Geneaology of Sultans), a literary text that appears to have been written after the fall of Malacca, and has numerous variants although generally following the same narrative.

Because it is written as a genealogy, some caution must be exercised when attempting to read the annals like a historical text. After all, the first part of the Malay Annals reads like a fantasy, recounting the lineage of the kings from Alexander the Great, the magical appearance of three princes at a mountain outside Palembang (Indonesia), and how one of these princes eventually came to found a city in Temasek (present-day Singapore). Already we might read these events as a literary device to legitimising the rule of the sultans by ascribing them to divine or mystical origins. Stripped from its fantastic elements, it might note the historical events of how Malacca was founded by a prince from Palembang, who first set up a settlement in Singapore, before moving to Malacca (the common interpretation today).

The second section of the Malay Annals deals with the founding of the Malacca and the events until the fall of the sultanate to the Portuguese. Here we read about the exploits of Hang Tuah, the admiral who is the most famous of all the Malay warriors, and Hang Li Po, a princess of China who marries one of the sultans of Malacca. A well in the World Heritage Site in Malacca has been associated with Hang Li Po, while Hang Tuah has an important role in Malay consciousness because it was he who famously proclaimed that the “Malays would never be wiped off the face of the earth”. These stories have become very much a part of the narrative that is taught to schoolchildren in Malaysia today.

Because of the way the Malay Annals is written (as a genealogy to highlight the reign and achievements of kings), its publication history (even the earliest version seems to have been written after the fall of Malacca) and its many versions (some scholars suggest the variations reflect differences in where the story was told to localise the text), it is unwise to accept the Malay Annals as a straight historical account. Hence the stories of people like Hang Li Po and Hang Tuah must be evaluated as whether they were actual, factual personalities, or if they were used analogies for military encounters and political alliances. It should be noted that Hang Tuah is also the main character for another piece of Malay literature, the Hikayat Hang Tuah (The Tale of Hang Tuah), but again for the same reasons it is difficult to differentiate the legendary aspects from the factual – almost like Arthurian lore. Professor Khoo asserts that with the lack of evidence, such figures should be relegated as myth and have no place in the history books. See:

  • BFM, 16 January 2012: Pendatang, Loyal Citizen Part 1: Early years of Chinese settlement (The radio interview that started it all)
  • The Star, 16 January 2012: Prof Khoo: No record of the existance of Princess Hang Li Po; its a myth
  • Free Malaysia Today, 16 January 2012: ‘Hang Li Po, Hang Tuah did not exist’
  • The Star, 17 January 2012: History books to stick to facts
  • The Star, 18 January 2012: Don: Even mythical objects found in history textbooks
  • The Star, 19 January 2012: Prove me wrong, Khoo tells detractors

Of course, this revision/revalation/upturning of history does not go down well, with many expressing disagreement and confusion over the respected scholar’s comments. It should be noted that despite assertions to the opposite, none of the detractors have provided any proof of the existence of these figures:

  • Malaysiakini, 18 January 2012: Suddenly what was history is now fiction
  • Free Malaysia Today, 18 January 2012: ‘It’s okay if Hang Tuah did not exist’
  • The Star, 19 January 2012: Shocked that Hang Tuah may be mythical
  • Bernama, via The Star, 20 January 2012: Prominent archaeologist convinced Hang Tuah not a mythtoday.com/2012/01/21/another-expert-backs-khoo-on-li-po-and-tuah/”>Another expert backs Khoo on Li Po and Tu
    ah
  • The Star, 22 January 2012: Is Hang Tuah fact or fiction?

Once again, the increasing ethnonationalism in Malaysia adds a political undertone in this story, much like last week’s story about the proto-Malays and the origins of the human race. The official history of Malaysia, as taught to schoolchildren, is seen to be heavily skewed towards the ethnic Malay population and under-represents the other minority groups. Professor Khoo, while a very respected scholarly figure in Malaysian society, is from the ethnic Chinese minority. Khoo has also said that the “main agenda for the [review] committee is to instil a sense of patriotism (among students)”. The education minister on the other hand, is thought to be a Malay supremacist, and part of his plans for the revision of the history syllabus is to make the subject compulsory at the high school level.

Share this:

  • Email
  • Print
  • Tweet
  • WhatsApp
  • More
  • Pocket

Like this:

Like Loading...

Subscribe for Southeast Asian Archaeology news updates

Latest Books

Sale The Oxford Handbook of Early Southeast Asia (Oxford Handbooks)
The Oxford Handbook of Early Southeast Asia...
$125.47
Buy on Amazon
Sale Monsoon Mosques: Arrival of Islam and the Development of a Mosque Vernacular
Monsoon Mosques: Arrival of Islam and the...
$29.57
Buy on Amazon
Sale Photography in Cambodia: 1866 to the Present
Photography in Cambodia: 1866 to the Present
$34.99
Buy on Amazon
Early Theravadin Cambodia: Perspectives from Art and Archaeology (Art and Archaeology of Southeast Asia: Hindu-Buddhist Traditions)
Early Theravadin Cambodia: Perspectives from Art...
$48.00
Buy on Amazon
Indigenous Archaeology in the Philippines: Decolonizing Ifugao History
Indigenous Archaeology in the Philippines:...
$60.00
Buy on Amazon
Ancient Southeast Asia: A Coloring Book for Adults with ancient artifacts, temples and sites from Thailand, Cambodia, Indonesia, Myanmar, the Philippines, Vietnam and more
Ancient Southeast Asia: A Coloring Book for Adults...
$9.99
Buy on Amazon
Digging Deep: A Journey into Southeast Asia's past
Digging Deep: A Journey into Southeast Asia's past
$30.00
Buy on Amazon
Indigenous Peoples, Heritage and Landscape in the Asia Pacific: Knowledge Co-Production and Empowerment (Routledge Studies in Indigenous Peoples and Policy)
Indigenous Peoples, Heritage and Landscape in the...
$48.95
Buy on Amazon
Coastal Shrines and Transnational Maritime Networks across India and Southeast Asia
Coastal Shrines and Transnational Maritime...
$37.69
Buy on Amazon
Returning Southeast Asia's Past: Objects, Museums, and Restitution (Art and Archaeology of Southeast Asia: Hindu-Buddhist Traditions)
Returning Southeast Asia's Past: Objects, Museums,...
$42.00
Buy on Amazon
Sea Nomads of Southeast Asia: From the Past to the Present
Sea Nomads of Southeast Asia: From the Past to the...
$32.00
Buy on Amazon

Last update on 2022-08-09 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Comments 2

  1. Anon says:
    11 years ago

    Menurut Andaya (2002), Hang Tuah, Hang Jebat dan Hang Kasturi adalah pemimpin ulung kaum Orang Asli. Kekuasaan Orang Asli dalam pemerintahan Melaka serta kerajaan-kerajaan melayu yang lain mengalami kemerosotan dengan kematian ketiga-tiga tokoh ini. Pendapat ini dipetik dari Pagan Races of the Malay Peninsula, Macmillan, London 1906 karangan Skeat, W.William and C.O. Blagden. Andaya juga memetik pendapat Juli Edo, seorang ahli antropologi dari etnik Semai yang mengatakan bahawa Hang Tuah dan Hang Jebat adalah Orang Asli. Hang Tuah ialah Orang Jakun (Winsdtedt, 1935). Hang Tuah dan keluarganya berpindah ke Hulu Perak selepas kematian Hang Jebat.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

SEAArch - Southeast Asian Archaeology

© 2019

Navigate Site

  • Resources
  • Countries
  • Topics
  • Research
  • Visit
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About

Follow

No Result
View All Result
  • Resources
  • Countries
    • Southeast Asia
    • Mainland Southeast Asia
      • Cambodia
      • Laos
      • Malaysia
      • Myanmar
      • Thailand
      • Vietnam
    • Island Southeast Asia
      • Brunei
      • Indonesia
      • Malaysia
      • Philippines
      • Singapore
      • Timor Leste
    • Peripheral Southeast Asia
  • Topics
    • Artifact Type
      • Architecture
      • Bones and Burials
      • Ceramics
      • Intangible Cultural Heritage
      • Lithics
      • Megaliths
      • Rock Art
      • Sculpture
    • Field
      • Anthropology
      • Bioarchaeology
      • Epigraphy
      • General Archaeology
      • Metallurgy and Metalworking
      • Paleontology
      • Underwater Archaeology
      • Visual Art
      • Zooarchaeology
    • Other Themes
      • Animism
      • Buddhism
      • Christianity
      • Disaster Risk Management
      • Hinduism
      • Islam
      • Tourism
  • Research
    • Online Lecture Library
    • Journals and Papers
    • Data Repositories and References
    • Archaeological Projects in Southeast Asia
    • Libraries
    • Books
    • Conferences
    • Laws and Legislation
    • Education
    • Digital Tools and Software
  • Visit
    • Virtual Archaeology
    • Exhibitions
    • Museums
    • Unesco World Heritage
  • Jobs
  • Subscribe
  • About
    • About
    • Supporters
    • Terms of Use
    • Privacy Policy
    • Contact

© 2019

Want more Southeast Asian Archaeology?
News in your inbox, twice a week

  • Also s

 


×
This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy and Cookie Policy.
%d bloggers like this: